Wildfire Winter?

…we are now witnessing yearly events, worsening and predictable events, that are causing direct and indirect devastation to people, crops and communities. We might call this increasingly predictable and destructive phenomenon “Wildfire Winter.”

Commentary by Marjorie Haun

Remember the Nuclear Winter scare of 30-something years ago? The theory of Nuclear Winter goes something like this:

Nuclear war breaks out between the Soviet Union and America. Following the path of Mutually Assured Destruction (MAD) the dueling super powers blast one another in retaliatory strikes obliterating 80 percent of the Northern Hemisphere’s population, and sending the entire civilized world into a maelstrom of ruination, degeneracy and protracted starvation.

But it gets worse…

The thermonuclear blasts are followed by unimaginably hot, fast moving fires that incinerate everything from living organisms to the soil itself, turning the earth into a blackened, fuming rubble, made even more dark by a smothering blanket of smoke, soot and deadly vapor covering the globe in its entirety.

Those groveling creatures which remain are subjected not just to the deadly aftermath of nuclear holocaust; radiation sickness, burns, economic and social collapse, and stone-age living conditions, but winter–gray, cold, endless winter, which freezes all attempts to grow crops and rebuild the ruined civilization of men. Nuclear Winter is the bleak, bitter denouement following the climactic nightmare of planetary nuclear war.

Sounds bad, eh? Well, fortunately this theory has yet to be tested, and we hope it never will. But there are prototypes, smaller versions of Nuclear Winter that humankind has endured for eons. Widespread crop failures doomed many farms in the summer of 1816, forcing mass migrations in the United States and around the globe. “The Year Without a Summer” saw temperatures plummet, interminable cloud cover, and endless days of cold and rain that supplanted the sunny warm conditions of growing season. 

There were no nuclear weapons in 1816, but in 1815 there was the colossal explosion of the Indonesian volcano, Mt. Tambora. The eruption of Tambora spewed ash, pumice, smoke and deadly gasses miles into the atmosphere, which then circled and engulfed the globe for more than a year. Lasting only a year or so, the effects of 1816’s Volcanic Winter were nonetheless, cataclysmic to hundreds of thousands.

Such events are thankfully rare, and although large volcanic eruptions occur every few years, they are smaller in scale with effects that are primarily localized and last only a few months. But we are now witnessing yearly events, worsening and predictable events, that are causing direct and indirect devastation to people, crops and communities. We might call this increasingly predictable and destructive phenomenon “Wildfire Winter.”

Wildfire season, 2018, provides a troubling case study of Wildfire Winter. Although relatively localized, the impact on farmers, ranchers, and food producers in general, has been crushing.

A September 5 article from Growing Produce cited the problems with smoke coverage and cooler temperatures:

Columbia Valley: Loss of Sunlight Will Hurt Potato Harvests

Waters, who serves the Columbia Valley in Washington, says its sun-drenched climate is ideal for crops like potatoes.

There has been heavy smoke coverage for more than two weeks, reducing sunlight, he told a local news radio station. That will likely delay harvest, which will likely be made up of slightly smaller potatoes, lowering the yield a little.

There’s also an increased chance for soil-borne pathogens, since more vines than usual will die off.

An August 29 article in Northwest News Network reported:

On Mike Pink’s potato farm at dawn, the sun is an angry red ball low in the sky.

This summer, wildfire smoke has blanketed much of the West for days and weeks. And that smoke has come between the sun and ripening crops.

Pink watches as his year’s work tumbles onto a fast-moving belt and into a waiting semi truck. He’s got most of his 1,600-acre potato fields yet to harvest on his 3,000-acre farm, spread over about 40 miles between Burbank and Basin City, Wash. And this thick smoke makes him nervous.

“When we’re not getting the sunlight like that, the plants aren’t growing. They are just kind of sitting there and doing nothing,” Pink says. “And every day that goes by, we lose a day of potential growth.”

Lost sunlight and too much heat means that Pink’s french fry potato crops aren’t gaining precious tons. He estimates one week of smoke will cost him around $34,000 for just one of his many fields.

“A couple hundred dollars or three, four hundred dollars an acre that just goes away might be your profit for the year,” Pink says. “And when you don’t get that profit, I mean, there’s always still those bills to pay. It makes things tough.”

An August 13 article in Western Farm Press details the harm to grapes from wildfires, reporting:

“It’s grapes we worry about the most,” said Susie Kocher, UC Cooperative Extension forestry and natural resources advisor. “In the past, there have been bad years when there was a lot of smoke where grapes were on the vine and wineries had to produce the smoky wine because of that effect.”

The article said grapes are unlike other agricultural products, in that the skins are permeable. Free volatile phenols created by burning wood become part of the grape itself.

And on August 14, City News published a piece about the eerie daytime light conditions caused by wildfires in British Columbia:

As more than 600 wildfires continue to burn across the province, residents shared images of the smoky skies on social media.

Many of the photos were from Prince George residents who captured an apocalyptic-looking evening as smoke darkened the sky.

Marie Dimmery and her family moved to Summit Lake a few months ago from Chilliwack. She says she was speechless when she saw the sky.

“This was truly unnerving for us to be in such a remote location and have it be dark.”

(Credit: Marie Dimmery/Twitter) Published by City News
(Credit: Nicole Wilson/Twitter) Published by City News

It is the confluence of misguided government forest management and failed environmental policies that impede logging, clearing, grazing and other effective approaches to fuel load mitigation, that makes Wildfire Winter so worrisome. Unlike massive volcanic eruptions, Wildfire Winter is not inevitable.  Human beings have a high degree of control over the size and intensity of forest and rangeland wildfires. It has been proven time and time again that where active forest management which treats trees as a resource, not sacred, untouchable edifices, the trees themselves–not to mention the wildlife and the people–benefit.

Wildfires will always occur in nature, and under well-managed forest conditions, fires can renew ecosystems and help some plant species to germinate. But “thou shalt not touch the trees” environmental policies have resulted in forests that are overgrown and clogged with diseased, dying, dead, tinder-dry trees. And these conditions make Wildfire Winter and its destructive consequences a sure thing.

As Reagan and Gorbachev took the threat of global nuclear war and the possibility of Nuclear Winter seriously, and pursued Detente in order to ensure the survival of the civilized world, governments at all levels need to take Wildfire Winter seriously, and pursue a path of sound resource management to ensure the survival of our forests, our crops, and the people who depend on them.

Free Range Report

Thank you for reading our latest report, but before you go…

Our loyalty is to the truth and to YOU, our readers!
We respect your reading experience, and have refrained from putting up a paywall and obnoxious advertisements, which means that we get by on small donations from people like you. We’re not asking for much, but any amount that you can give goes a long way to securing a better future for the people who make America great.


For as little as $1 you can support Free Range Report, and it takes only a moment.

About the author